Finn:
I can't believe she told you.
Kurt:
I can't believe you didn't. We're supposed to be brothers.
Finn:
Look, I didn't want to put you in an awkward position with Burt. Okay? I don't want him to know yet.
Kurt:
And you think something you have to keep from everyone you love might not be the best idea in the first place?
Finn:
Don't get down on me about this, dude. Rachel's like the only good thing I've got going in my life right now.
Kurt:
No she isn't, Finn. Look, I get you've had a rough year with finding out who your dad really is and losing the scholarship. But you're a star, Finn. Just as bright as Rachel. You just don't believe in yourself.
Finn:
Yeah, well the proof's in the pudding. Okay? And my pudding pretty much sucks.
Kurt:
Look, I'm not telling you that you shouldn't marry Rachel. I love her despite all her crazy and I think that you'd be lucky to marry her. One day. But I don't want you to just turn yourself into nothing but the guy who holds her purse on the red carpet.
Finn:
I'm getting to the point in my life where I kind of need to be honest with myself about who I am.
Finn:
Not you. Not Rachel.
Kurt:
That's the point, Finn. There are plenty of us, trust me. The one thing that Glee clubs and theater programs don't have is the hot, straight football player who can sing and sort of dance. You're unique, Finn. Now I can't see this proposal thing as anything else but you giving up on yourself.
Finn:
No, no it's not. At least I don't think it is.
Kurt:
Your time isn't up, Finn. It's just beginning.